Dog Training Organizations Agree ONLY Positive Reinforcement Training is Acceptable


organizations accepting new dog training standards

Share

Shock collars – in essence those are the two words few are speaking out loud has now brought nearly every dog training organization together, literally on the same page to stand up against their use. However, there’s one glaring outlier, the Certification Council for Professional Dog Trainers (CCPDT).

Dog training Joint Standards of Practice and Professional Code of Ethics is an all-new position statement which doesn’t mention shock collars by name but it might as well. For the first time ever, it’s a line in a sand drawn to unconditionally support positive reinforcement training and without any prearranged “loopholes” or “workarounds.”

This new statement says, “Professionals shall utilize non-aversive and/or positive-reinforcement-based training, and support the animal’s emotional well-being and comfort.”

And it goes on to say, “Professionals shall not use training, management, or behavior modification techniques that rely on fear, pain, distress, or harm. This includes, but is not limited to:

  • Positive-punishment-based strategies
  • Management practices that significantly restrict the animal’s movement, choice, or ability to perform normal behaviors
  • Intentional deprivation of food, water, or social interaction
  • Tools or equipment designed to cause, or that functionally result in causing, fear, pain, or startle.”

Among the organizations signing on to these standards, Victoria Stilwell Academy, Academy of Animal Behavior, Assistance Dogs International, Association for Professional Dog Training International, Grisha Stewart Academy, International Association of Animal Behavior Consultants, IAABC Foundation. Karen Pryor Academy and Understanding Horses,

However, CCPDT, arguably among most significant certifiers of animal behavior did not sign on to this document. This doesn’t mean that trainers certified by this organization are inherently going to be a concern, as most signed on in good faith. Some of those are now disassociating themselves with CCPDT.

Should Dog Trainers Be Licensed?

I endorse the idea that dog trainers should be licensed and regulated based on best practices. The welfare of dogs and the profession have long needed this. The CCPDT has long sought to achieve this goal. CCPDT enlisted other important organizations to sign on to their notion of all trainers being on the same page.

Earlier in the year CCPDT announced their plan which included a statement for best practices for dog trainers. However, CCPDT was willing to fly in the face of science, not to mention all the organizations outlined above and to accept e-collars or shock collars, prong collars (pointy collars some dogs wear in cartoons) and chain link choke collars.

I suspect CCPDT would have called their view as a compromise to get this overall boilerplate certification accepted by all or maybe the organization truly support shock collars and the training philosophy which goes along with them. However, by allowing aversive equipment and presumably along with that punishment-based training techniques, the other long list of respected organizations outlined above immediately pulled out and CCCPDT was left standing alone.

Now those organizations – via this new position statement – have together and for the first time ever unanimously said that any type of dog training other than positive reinforcement is simply unacceptable.

Earlier this month, a court agreed $1.9 million California consumer class action arising out of misrepresentations and omissions by parent company Radio Systems in connection with its manufacture, sale, marketing, and advertising of shock collar products under the brand name PetSafe® was proven successful.